Skip to the specimen
Feathers, Skeletons & Nests

Specimen note · a term used on this site

The Remodel Rule

The remodel rule is the first question Feathers, Skeletons & Nests puts to any odd bone: what existing structure was it remodelled from?

How it is used

Think of a body as an old house that has been lived in for hundreds of millions of years and never cleared for a rebuild: rooms are knocked through and walls go up, but the old timbers tend to stay in use. The comparison is only a picture, yet it explains the habit of looking first for an older part. A mole's hand shows how it works. It seems to carry a sixth finger, but a 2012 developmental study by Mitgutsch and colleagues found that the extra "thumb" is an enlarged sesamoid bone of the wrist, not a new digit. The rule sends the reader to the wrist rather than to an invented finger.

The page on homologous structures applies the rule to that mole's hand, set beside the forelimbs of a human, three cetaceans and a horse.

Where it stops

The remodel rule is a habit for reading skeletons, not a law of evolution. New structures do arise, and genes that have been copied can take on new work, so the rule can point the wrong way. Pages that use it say where it fails, and its exceptions are written with "usually" or "in most lineages". How claims behind it are sourced is described on One bone, one source.