Skip to the specimen
Feathers, Skeletons & Nests

Open Drawer: About Feathers, Skeletons & Nests

Same bones, different lives.

A bat's wing holds a hand. A whale's flipper holds finger bones, and a giraffe's long neck is built on seven vertebrae, the same number found in most mammals. Feathers, Skeletons & Nests is a guide to comparative anatomy and the evidence for evolution, written for anyone who stops at a skeleton in a museum case, a fossil in a slab of rock or a nest an animal has built. Each page takes one bone group, fossil, structure or named branch of the family tree and lays out the evidence for what it is.

The drawings follow one rule across the whole site: the same bone keeps the same colour in every animal and on every page. A forelimb drawn on one page can be set beside a forelimb drawn on another and read straight across, humerus to humerus and finger to finger.

What the name covers

Each word in the name points to part of the site. Feathers stands for feathered fossils and the bones of birds: Archaeopteryx, Sinosauropteryx, the question of whether birds are dinosaurs, and the bones inside a bird's wing. The site does not identify feathers or explain how feathers are built or coloured. Skeletons is the comparison of vertebrate skeletons. Nests stands for animal builders of every kind. Fossils and family trees are not in the name, but two of the four sections below are given to them.

The four drawers

  • Skeletons: homologous and vestigial structures, one bone group followed from species to species, and bones that changed jobs. The first pages cover the finger bones of a beluga, the hip bones of a whale, the jaw bones that became middle-ear bones, the neck of a giraffe, the ribs and backbone inside a turtle's shell, and the three fingers of a bird's wing.
  • Fossils: how bone and wood turn to stone, and what named fossils can and cannot show, among them Archaeopteryx, Tiktaalik, early whales, Sinosauropteryx, petrified wood and the ichthyosaur found by Mary Anning and her family.
  • Animal Builders: mounds, bowers, dams and colony nests, read one species at a time: termite mounds, the courts of bowerbirds, beaver dams and the shared nests of sociable weavers.
  • Lineages: where named animal groups sit among their relatives, such as birds among the dinosaurs, humans among the apes and a crab-like body shape that evolved more than once.

The pages serve students looking for the evidence behind a textbook claim, biology teachers who need figures they are free to reuse, museum visitors and walkers who want to know where a skeleton or fossil fits, and naturalists who have stood beside a mound or a dam and wondered how it was made.

Where the site stops

  • Human health stays out. Human bones appear only beside the bones of other animals. Bone density, posture, joints, pain and diet are not covered.
  • No fossil trade. Pages give no prices, valuations, authenticity opinions, collecting localities or digging methods.
  • No legal advice. Rules on keeping feathers, nests, eggs, bones or fossils differ by country and by who owns the land. Where a page touches on them, it states the rule and names the official source. In the United States, for instance, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service explains the Migratory Bird Treaty Act on its own pages, and the National Park Service sets out the laws that protect fossils on federal lands.
  • Living structures are left alone. Active mounds, nests, dams and colonies are described from published studies. No page asks readers to approach, open or disturb one, and pages that describe them say so in the same paragraph.
  • No invented skin. Extinct animals are shown as fossils, bones and historical skeleton plates. No life reconstruction of an extinct animal appears on the site, generated or otherwise.
  • Other things left out: feather identification, pet care, news reports on newly described species, ranked lists of the biggest or fastest, and imagined fights between dinosaurs. Pages on the origins of birds or humans set out the scientific evidence and leave religious belief alone.

What the site holds to

These are editorial positions. They are argued, they can be disagreed with, and each stops where the evidence stops.

The site reads every skeleton, nest and fossil as a record of remodelling, not as a blueprint. The first question about an odd part is what it was changed from. That is a choice about where to start reading, not a law of evolution: new structures do arise, and pages say where the habit points the wrong way.

  • A tree has no top. The order of the tips on a family tree says nothing about rank, and turning any branch point around leaves every relationship unchanged. No living species stands at the end of evolution.
  • Bones over guesswork. Much of an extinct animal's soft tissue is inferred, and a polished but wrong picture travels further than an honest skeleton. The site would rather show the bones.
  • "Living fossil" deserves retirement. Horseshoe crabs and coelacanths have gone on evolving like every other living species, and the label keeps the picture of a ladder alive.
  • Humans did not evolve from chimpanzees. Humans and chimpanzees share an ancestral population that no longer exists. Pages on human origins keep three levels apart: living individuals, species and ancestral populations.
  • Animal buildings are evolved behaviour. Calling a beaver dam or a termite mound a work of genius is as thin a reading as calling it pure instinct. Pages ask what each structure does and what the published studies show.

Three terms of the site's own

  • The remodel rule: the first question to ask of an odd bone, which is what existing structure it was remodelled from.
  • The stowaway bone: a bone that changed jobs and stayed in the body, like an old beam carried into a new room.
  • Node blindness: reading a rooted family tree by its tips alone and missing that each branch point stands for a common ancestor.

How claims are checked

Statements about anatomy, fossils and animal behaviour are tied to published studies, open datasets and public-domain classics, and every page lists its sources. Each source entry also notes how much of it was read: the complete paper, or an abstract alone. Trees are redrawn from the Open Tree of Life synthetic tree or, where fossils are involved, from published trees, with the data source and retrieval date on the figure and no branch lengths. Counts, sizes and unit conversions are recalculated, and where the sources allow it, the table behind a figure can be downloaded as a CSV file. One bone, one source gives the rules in detail.

Pictures and colours

Photographs and plates come from openly licensed or public-domain sources, each with its own credit line. Nineteenth-century anatomy and fossil plates appear as historical documents, dated and credited. Pictures marked Illustration are generated images. They show living animals in their surroundings and never a fossil, a specimen or an extinct species. They are not photographs, specimens or historical records, and they are not drawn to scale. Anything that carries a scale, a colour key, a bone chart or a tree is drawn from data instead. Licences and credit lines are explained on Plates for classrooms.

The site's blue is the Prussian blue of the cyanotype, the sun-printing process that nineteenth-century naturalists used to lay plants and specimens directly on paper and print them as pale shapes on blue. The warmer colours come from the subjects: bone white for a cleaned skeleton, amber-brown for mineralised bone, olive for the twigs of nests and branches, and an iron-oxide ochre for the stain that iron-rich sediment leaves on fossils.

Byline and errors

Every page carries the byline Feathers, Skeletons & Nests.

A wrong bone count, a misplaced branch, a misdated fossil or a faulty credit line can be reported to contact@feathersskeletonsandnests.com, with the page and the source that disagrees. Email is the only route in, with no web form behind it, and no deadline for an answer is set. Corrections are listed with their dates on Relabelled, and the corrected page notes the change at its foot. Tag a question describes a helpful report, and Counting visits sets out what a visit sends.